• Welcome to the General Discussion forum for UAD users!

    Please note that this forum is user-run, although we're thrilled to have so much contribution from Drew, Will, and other UA folks!

    Feel free to discuss both UAD and non-UAD related subjects!

    1) Please do not post technical issues here. Please use our UAD Support Forums instead.

    2) Please do not post complaints here. Use the Unrest Forum instead. They have no place in the the General Discussion forum.

    Threads posted in the wrong forum will be moved, so if you don't see your thread here anymore, please look in the correct forum.

    Lastly, please be respectful.

ProTools AND Logic?

Archmart

Active Member
Hey Hey!

I've got a ProTools 002R rig running on a Dual 1.8 G5 with 4 UAD-1s in an Expansion Chassis. Needless to say, I love the UAD plugs.

Recently, I got tagged to teach an Intro to Music Tech class and I was given the academic version of Logic Express. I've only spent maybe 30 minutes messing with the program on a classroom workstation and I haven't actually opened my own copy of it. I'm considering whether or not I should throw in my own cash to get the full version. It's a matter of $350.00, whereas if I decide I want it later, the academic version of Logic Express is not upgradeable, so I'd be paying $500 (for the academic version)

My initial interest is mostly related to getting around the delay compensation issue. Of course, I'm very steeped in ProTools (both LE and HD3) and Logic just looks like candy, a toy.

I need to get down to business learning the ins and outs of it so I can introduce my class to it, but I'm hesitant to open the box because I'm wondering if it would be worth it to get the full version.

I'm mostly into straight up Rock and Roll and Jazz with ocassional bits of classical and some broadway type stuff. I'm not really too into electronica or expecting to do too much with virtual instruments and such, although I am leaning more and more toward interest in adding more keys and analog synth type sounds to my work. The ease of composition which I experienced in that brief half-hour WAS intriguing and definitely appeals to the musician side of me, but my living is made off of being an audio engineer and not a composer/musician.

Can any of you power users advise me? Besides the delay compensation, why do you use Logic? Would you buy it even if you already had a ProTools rig going? In my case I also make use of a full HD3, 5.1 Genelec, Augsburger designed room, so I've always considered that compatibility factor between my project studio at home and the real studio at work to be key.

Thanks,
Archmart
 

Ashermusic

Active Member
Archmart said:
Hey Hey!

I've got a ProTools 002R rig running on a Dual 1.8 G5 with 4 UAD-1s in an Expansion Chassis. Needless to say, I love the UAD plugs.

Recently, I got tagged to teach an Intro to Music Tech class and I was given the academic version of Logic Express. I've only spent maybe 30 minutes messing with the program on a classroom workstation and I haven't actually opened my own copy of it. I'm considering whether or not I should throw in my own cash to get the full version. It's a matter of $350.00, whereas if I decide I want it later, the academic version of Logic Express is not upgradeable, so I'd be paying $500 (for the academic version)

My initial interest is mostly related to getting around the delay compensation issue. Of course, I'm very steeped in ProTools (both LE and HD3) and Logic just looks like candy, a toy.

I need to get down to business learning the ins and outs of it so I can introduce my class to it, but I'm hesitant to open the box because I'm wondering if it would be worth it to get the full version.

I'm mostly into straight up Rock and Roll and Jazz with ocassional bits of classical and some broadway type stuff. I'm not really too into electronica or expecting to do too much with virtual instruments and such, although I am leaning more and more toward interest in adding more keys and analog synth type sounds to my work. The ease of composition which I experienced in that brief half-hour WAS intriguing and definitely appeals to the musician side of me, but my living is made off of being an audio engineer and not a composer/musician.

Can any of you power users advise me? Besides the delay compensation, why do you use Logic? Would you buy it even if you already had a ProTools rig going? In my case I also make use of a full HD3, 5.1 Genelec, Augsburger designed room, so I've always considered that compatibility factor between my project studio at home and the real studio at work to be key.

Thanks,
Archmart
I have to leave so a quick response:

Logic overall is a better tool for composers and PT is overall a better tool for engineers. More later.
 

digigem

Member
Logic would be More intresting for kids to learn with, No limtations on Audio tracks unlike Pro Tools Le( Music tool kit,upgrades to 48 trks-More Money!!!), midi is straight forward, import and export OMF formats (pro tools le need digi translator-Extra money!!!). More Plug-ins available. Compatable with any Audio interface. emm. cant rember the rest . i'll let you know when i remeber. :lol: :D
 

Archmart

Active Member
Hey Hey!

Any issues running ProTools LE and Logic Pro on same G5?

(I assume they won't both run at the same time or sync together, but do any conflicts come up with both on same computer?

Archmart
 
There should be no issues running both apps on the same machine. The only thing I would check / watch is how Logic works with the 002r. I had an 002r a couple years ago, Logic worked (version 6.x) but not 100% (say 95%).
The Digidesign drivers are probably better now, so this probably won't be an issue.
Logic does support DAE, so you should be able to use with the full blown hardware in the big studio.
I love Logic. Digital Performer is a close second (very Protools-esq).

The effects that come with Logic are very good. The pitch plugin (Time Machine) also works very well.

Definately a steal if you can get into the full version for $350.
Regards,
Rich
 
UAD Bundle Month
Top